The Amazing Atheist spits on the memory of Amanda Todd [TW: bullying, sexual shaming, self-harm, suicide]

You may have read about the heartbreaking story of Amanda Todd, a Canadian teenager who recently posted a much-watched YouTube video (posted below) detailing the bullying and harassment she’d endured online and in real life. This past Wednesday, she was found dead, the apparent victim of suicide.

Here, from the Vancouver Sun, is the basic outline of Amanda’s story:

Amanda was 12 years old when she made a mistake that would haunt her until her death three years later.

Her ordeal started while she was fooling around online with friends. She probably didn’t think it was risky behaviour when she lifted her top to flash the person who was flattering her at the other end of the webcam.

Amanda’s moment of indiscretion was not unusual for someone her age: Sexting and using webcams to share sexual photos is a growing trend among children, some so young they are still in grade school.

“The Internet stalker she flashed kept stalking her,” said Carol. “Every time she moved schools he would go undercover and become a Facebook friend. What the guy did was he went online to the kids who went to (the new school) and said that he was going to be a new student — that he was starting school the following week and that he wanted some friends and could they friend him on Facebook.”

“He eventually gathered people’s names and sent Amanda’s video to her new school.”

The video and photos went to teachers, to parents, to Facebook friends, which lead to repeated taunts: “Oh, there’s the porn star.” …

Amanda was the victim of unrelenting blackmail. And the cyberspace stalker was aided by people in Amanda’s real-world life — kids who would share the photos on their cellphones, kids who would gang up to hurl first verbal abuse and then fists at her.

Amanda’s story illustrates what can happen to young girls when sexualized images of them floating around online, whether they’ve put these pictures up themselves in a moment of poor judgement or whether someone has stolen them from password-locked private photo albums, or whether someone has surreptitiously taken an “upskirt” or “down-the-blouse” or some other compromising picture of them in public. This is the sort of damage that things like the Jailbait and Creepshots subreddits can do to young girls. This is why it’s so important that things like these subreddits be shut the fuck down.

Sadly, even after her suicide, Amanda remains the target of bullies and assholes online.

One of these assholes? The MRA and atheist videoblogger and all-around terrible person known to the world as The Amazing Atheist, whom we first met when he had a Reddit meltdown and started spewing misogynistic abuse at his detractors. Now he’s spitting on Amanda’s memory.

Mocking the format of Amanda’s video, in which told her story by holding up sheets of paper to the camera describing the abuse she’s endured, The Amazing Atheist posted this picture to his Tumblr blog earlier today:

I simply can’t comprehend the mind of someone whose response to Amanda’s story is this. Beyond awful.

Here’s Amanda’s video:

About David Futrelle

I run the blog We Hunted the Mammoth, which tracks (and mocks) online misogyny. My writing has appeared in a wide variety of places, including Salon,, the Washington Post, the New York Times Book Review and Money magazine. I like cats.

Posted on October 13, 2012, in bullying, douchebaggery, harassment, men who should not ever be with women ever, misogyny, MRA, reddit, YouTube and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 270 Comments.

  1. I read the article someone linked above. The article was good, but the apologists in the comment thread made me throw up in my mouth a little. They could of just kept their mouths shut and let people empathize and mourn this poor girl, but something about framing her tragedy as driven by sexism and misogyny just made some of these guys livid.

    But still, what couldn’t they just keep their mouths shut? I mean, just this once?

    I read all those comments, too, and they were awful. They were trying to make her mom into the villian and the stalker as either a victim or another woman. If they had actually read the stories or watched her video, they would have known better, unless they were just straight up lying.

  2. @Sporklift
    It’s bizarre to hear that your mother was fiercely anti-bullying and yet she didn’t recognise what was happening to you, and she didn’t do anything about it.

    Have you spoken to her about it now you’re older? Does she believe it now? What did she consider to be ‘real’ bullying? What do you think she should/could have done at the time to fix things?

  3. Gotta love facebook. Let’s see what the responses to this incident were: blaming the girl, blaming the parents, wanting the stalker to be raped/tortured/executed (even by vigilantes, it’s ok). Dammit, I’m forgetting some.

    Well, anyway, FB is just not that good for your sanity.

  4. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    Sir Bodsworth – if only!

    Mind you there are those out there who’d listen to their own horrible messages and still think they were heroes.

  5. @theboinicmommy

    I saw those comments on that article too. If you look at the username of the one trying to pin the stalker as a lesbian, you’ll notice it looks very, very familiar.

    For those who don’t want to look it up (provided it hasn’t been deleted) it’s our old friend “Dr.” Pell. I guess the lying little troll followed the link too.

  6. There are “people” who live today that are no different than the people who lives in the times of the Roman coliseums, the theaters of death that pervaded that era of violence and butchery. Sick, twisted, perverse, and loathsome people who won’t stop a second to see the pain and misery they cause other people from their indifference to their fellow human beings, beings as valuable and vital as they think they are. These “people” can blame the mother and father for not being there, or whomever, but they don’t own the intelligence and compassion to blame the real perpetrators of her slide into suicide – their inhumanity.

  7. Oh fuck, Dave’s not letting them spew their shit here, so they take it out on this poor blogger I linked who has no familiarity with these fuckwits whatever. Poor person must be wondering what the hell happened to the internet to make everyone so awful.

  8. Did anyone call the little weasel-turd out?

  9. What the hell is wrong with this guy?

    Shit, I received some pretty traumatic bullying in Jr. High. I wore a shirt with Fido Dido wearing a clown hat, and some asshole told everyone it was a klansman. For the next 3 months, I had people I didn’t know telling me their friend saw a burnt cross in my front yard. I had girls smack me in the head in class without repercussion. I had friends ditch me in favour of the bullies, to the point where they participated in helping me get beat up. I began having suicidal thought, which honestly have never really gone away, even 25 years later.

    I was lucky; I still had good friends and a fantastic family, and the fear of hurting them by my actions outweighed the pain I was going through. It was the only thing preventing my fantasies of walking into the gym locker room with pipe bombs and several pounds of nails from becoming a reality.

    And TAA has gone through bullying himself? How can anyone who has gone through that sort of bullying have anything but sympathy for Amanda Todd?

  10. Amazing Atheist, you’re an amazing asshole!

  11. Pecunium, I think you’re going to have to be a bit more specific about the weasel turd in question.

  12. Pell. I was wondering if anyone who saw his comments there pointed out what a sad sack of shit he is.

  13. I see he’s also an admitted liar, unless of course he killed himself later that day?

  14. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    I see he’s also an admitted liar, unless of course he killed himself later that day?

    That takes me back to the 1990s and (this is a reference probably only Aussies will know about) that idiot Pauline Hanson and her “If you are watching this video, I am dead” nonsense. Which she wasn’t, and isn’t.

  15. “Amanda was 12 years old when she made a mistake that would haunt her until her death three years later.”

    Oh, fuck this shit! Mistake? She made a mistake? Consensually posting a picture of your boobs isn’t a mistake. Spreading a picture of someone’s breasts without the breasts-owner’s consent is sexual assault. It wasn’t a “mistake” that haunted her; it was a rapey piece of rat shit.

  16. The hacker group Annymous has released the identity of a man they allege is Amamda Todds tomentor.

  17. pillowinhell: That’s great that they found him, although I fear they’re going to just do the same thing he did to Amanda to him. Even though this guy was disgusting, nobody should do that to him. They should just get him arrested and punished by the law. Has anyone told the police yet?

  18. i was a weird kid, and a minority at my school. (inner city magnet school) i only attended 1 year of high school, and in the normal run of things, i would have been bullied. my brother, in the grade below, was bullied and harassed daily. the only thing that saved me from bullying was that pretty much everyone thought i was crazy. i was not a normal kid, and i showed it. it’s a shame that the only thing that kept those kids from harassing me was fear. they saw what i did everyday, they didn’t want to know what i might do if upset. i never saw anyone bullied in front of me, because i sure would have jumped in. i agree with the poster upthread, skeptifem? who thinks the environment of school makes for a rigid and hierarchical system in which there have to be losers. the stupid thing is that most of those “high school winners” get out into the world and are suddenly REALLY not important. the only answer i have is reforming schools, although, i would have to say that romney’s behaviour has completely been that of the bully he was as a teen. so it doesn’t always go away.

  19. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    That’s what I was wondering. Vigilantism is wrong anyway, but with the additonal “what if it’s NOT him?” question it gets even uglier. Give the details to the police and let them do their job.

  20. I just looked it up, and from the image I’ve seen, it’s circumstantial evidence that he did this to Amanda Todd. It may not be him. However, it’s pretty much certain that he did have a victim who was a child. So he should be reported to the police.
    With all the attention from the media this case has, we shouldn’t have to worry about the police putting off an investigation for this like they do with many rape cases.

  21. Have they handed this info over to law enforcement? Not only is just handing it over to the general public a bad idea because of potential vigilante stuff, it’s also possible that the cops may already have eliminated this person from this particular investigation, or that leaking the name too soon might interfere with their ability to actually get a conviction.

    Basically I’m hoping they’ve done the smart thing and just helpfully passed on whatever info they have to the proper law enforcement agencies.

  22. And will the evidence be admissible in court?

  23. Cthulhu's Intern

    Cassandra: I don’t know if they have. Probably a few, but judging from what I know about most cases of Internet justice, I can make an educated guess that most haven’t and are probably sending him pizza or something.
    princessbonbon: Yes. They didn’t do anything illegal, surprisingly. They managed to find it entirely through information he posted on the Internet and Google cache. This guy is apparently a huge participant in “jailbait” websites.

  24. Here’s a weird development: The guy identified as Amanda’s Todd’s blackmailer was in court today on charges unrelated to Todd (but related to him being an alleged pedo shitstain):

    The man identified by Anonymous appeared Monday at Surrey provincial court house, where he faces charges of sexual assault and sexual interference with a minor in a case unrelated to Todd.

    He told CTV News he knew the 15-year-old, but insisted he was her friend. He said he helped identify a man in New York who was harassing her, and claims he passed that information to the RCMP.

  25. All that needs to be said HAS been said in the above comments.
    People, we need NEW strategies to deal with all this. I am a relative newcomer to YouTube & the world of YouTube commenting, but after only several weeks of dealing with the likes of Amazing Atheist & the MRA, I can see the same action-response-action-response cycles have been going on for years.
    They call for “reasoned debate”, but its just a waste of time, as through the likes of GirlWritesShit & Wanking Mr E, they’ve all learned to stop any discussion from getting past the first point, by endlessly calling up bogus rules of “Socratic Debate” , & infinitely challenging you with endless logistical nitpicking. Fuck it ! Don’t play by their rules. It’s not a “level playing field” to begin with.
    We are right & don’t need to “prove” it. It’s not a televised debate. We won’t change their views & they won’t change ours.
    As a start, I could make the following suggestions –
    Find the good videos & “like” them. Don’t bother watching the shit (you know what they’re saying anyway, & every view gives them another “point”) but “dislike” it anyway. There are a few amazing asshole videos where the vote is so split that it could be tipped by just a few dozen people.
    Encourage EVERYONE you know to do likewise (perhaps focusing on particular postings).
    PLEASE leave messages of support on the good videos. Sometimes dozens of people have “liked” a Youtube video, but NONE of them have actually commented, leaving the comments boxes to be filled up only by the assholes. Imagine how this makes the video maker feel.
    Make your own videos & get them out there.
    Be CREATIVE – they can’t. Instead of leaving insults or offering “reasoned argument” to be endlessly nitpicked over – do something different. Reply by typing their comment backwards or ask them a zen koan, & that quickly stops them ranting their drivel. They’re thrown off script, & they don’t know what to do.
    Finally, try to make links between each other & team up with like minded souls on the internet. So many people (myself included) seem to be working away at this alone, yet I get the impression that there are a great number of us who feel the same way.
    I have been inspired to make a few little videos of my own, & would appreciate if people could watch them, “like” them & leave a comment (& if you want to work together, just say so & I’ll get right back to you). I don’t know jackshit about leaving “links” here (I’m very new to computers) but if you go to YouTube & type in “Feminism otherseed” the videos will come up. Being a newcomer, I need all the gracious support I can get, as I notice the haters get in quick.
    I’m up for working with anyone, in any respect, in order to challenge all the internet misogyny.

  26. The Stepford Knife

    “I’m pretty convinced that US culture particularly hates teenage girls. Make the kind of mistakes common to all people but really common with people your age, and one that only hurts yourself? You’re a pariah and deserve everything you get.”

    Wordspinner, sadly this isn’t confined to the US. In the UK we recently had a case where a married 30-year-old teacher, Jeremy Forrest, had an affair with a 15-year-old pupil, which made the news when they ran away to France together. Being under 16 means she is not legally capable of consenting to go with him, so this is technically abduction and this is what Forrest has been charged with. This seems fairly straightforward and simple to understand, along with the idea that adults in positions of responsibility should not exploit the naive and hormonal lovestruck teenagers in their care, but look at most online news reports and you’ll see hundreds of depressing comments expressing sympathy for the poor defenceless man who was seduced by the wicked 15-year-old temptress, suggestions that she should be punished for what she did to the poor ickle man,and general creepiness, slut-shaming and victim-blaming.

    Here we also have similar problems with topless photos being circulated on Facebook and elsewhere, and these being used for the purposes of blackmail. There’s a good article on it here:

    Like many of the commenters on this article I’m just glad I went to an all-girls’ school, and at a time before cameraphones were invented.

  27. The Kittehs’ Unpaid Help: As soon as we found out his cancer was terminal, my dad left VERY specific instructions for what to do when he passed. They basically consisted of:
    1) Have a party
    2) A BIG party
    3) Make everyone wear hawaiian shirts (the louder, the better) and leis
    4) Provide lots of good booze and food
    5) Play good music

    It was pretty awesome. Having a party didn’t make it any easier to lose him, but being encouraged to remember the fun times made the first month or so a lot easier to bear.

  28. I hate this guy, I really do. He reminds me way too much of a stalker I had in high school. Similar narcissism and sexism, same type of arguments, same radiating hatred, he even looks similar. He isn’t the same person, but boy they would make good friends.

    This girl was a victim. She had no chance to become a survivor. That man and those bullies are her murderers as far as I’m concerned. It had nothing to do with whatever “mistake” she made. She didn’t “mess up”. A stalker and bullies happened to her. She didn’t invite them with “risky behaviour” anymore than a woman does by walking alone at night or by getting drunk. I’m so sick of articles framing it like this happened because of what she did, even if they’re otherwise well-meaning. THEY’RE PART OF THE PROBLEM.

    Also, back up where I said “consensual”, I wasn’t aware at the time that it was a grown-ass man, and that he had coerced her into it. That just makes it worse. Not only was she bullied for being sexually assaulted, she was bullied for being sexually assaulted…that was a result of a previous sexual assault.

  29. These past few months, Amanda Todd’s death has been one of way too fucking (sorry, David) many within these last few months, and I just…I can barely articulate how I feel about it. The anti-bullying stuff I’m a follower of on fb have been going into overdrive.

    Yet sometimes it feels like all that we try and do to end all this, people like The Amazing Asshole (borrowing that one; it’s so fitting!), the slut-shamers, blamers and so fourth, just yell louder. That’s what really, really depresses me.

    Amanda, RIP.

  30. Some Grey Bloke just made a rather timely video mentioning TAA:

  31. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    Curse this soundless computer! I’ll have to listen to this at home.

  32. Don’t you see it?! God didn’t do this, facebook didn’t do this, WE did it. The people who ignored Amanda’s cries for help, the people who mock of her and just add to the pile, and the direct responsible for iniating all this, they do it.

  33. Who here said that God did it, etc.?

  34. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    Saying “facebook didn’t do this” is pretty strange given it’s people on these sites – and owners of sites who refuse to police them at all – who are responsible for this sort of thing.

  35. >>They call for “reasoned debate”, but its just a waste of time, as through the likes of GirlWritesShit & Wanking Mr E, they’ve all learned to stop any discussion from getting past the first point, by endlessly calling up bogus rules of “Socratic Debate”

    Yeah yeah, we all know he’s an arrogant asshole, but there’s another side to the Amazing Atheist. He’s also really stupid. His arguments are dishonest and fake.

    Socrates never tried to pass off loaded strawman horseshit like this as “reasoned debate”

  36. It isnt awful the way he responded to her. First off, she flashed the camera. Yes the bullying wasnt needed, but SHE FLASHED HER CHEST . SHE DIDNT RESPECT HERSELF, why don’t you people comprehend that? GET OFF THE DAMN BANDWAGON.

  37. Eva, you’re saying she deserved to die because she flashed her chest? Congratulations on being a terrible human being.

  38. Argenti Aertheri

    “Amanda was 12 years old when she made a mistake that would haunt her until her death three years later.

    Her ordeal started while she was fooling around online with friends. She probably didn’t think it was risky behaviour when she lifted her top to flash the person who was flattering her at the other end of the webcam.”

    Three. Fucking. Years. That isn’t “well of course people commented on her boobs”, that’s continual harassment for years. And fuck, she was a teenager, shouldn’t this have counted as child porn and thus everyone who viewed it looked into and the video taken down and the whole thing gone hush hush in no time flat?

    But wtf part of flashing a camera online makes harassing her in person acceptable?!

  39. He truly is an evil man, isn’t he? He’s a complete sociopath that deserves nothing but an eternity of pain and suffering.

  40. Nope, I’ve read that 3 times and it still makes no sense.

    Who is “he”? Who are you? And what are you doing posting this nonsense on a months old thread?

  41. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    Either Jake B genuinely thinks the Unamazing Douchebag is a sociopath who deserves pain and suffering,


    Jake B is a troll who’s sneering at the idea of anyone criticising said Unamazing Douchebag.

    Either way, adding a comment to a months-old thread is a strange thing to do. It’s not like this is a blog with few visitors and no current posts.

  42. Or it’s an attempted “gotcha” & Jake B is hoping we’ll agree with him so he can tell us how horrible we are …

    Is originality in trolling too much to ask for?🙂

  43. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    Apparently so! I think some crappy little factory somewhere turns out our trolls. Such tawdry cheapjack stuff they are these days.

  44. Yeah, the wheels fall off before they’re even properly played with.😦

  45. The Kittehs' Unpaid Help

    They remind me of the tables full of junky toys in shops like Moore’s back in the sixties … in those days Made In Hong Kong was about the bottom of the heap for quality, and you’d have to be five or under to be taken in by it.

  46. You! Quit giving my first name and last initial a bad name! This site isn’t big enough for TWO Jake B.’s

  47. Okay bullying is wrong. and I find what the photo TAA made is disgusting BUT quit calling him a misogynist just because he does not agree with all the crazy unstable misandrist nutjobs who call themselves feminists.

    But there was a boy who killed himself over bullying because of the way he looks. Where is his coverage and attention. Or does the media not care simply because the boy was ugly and Amanda Todd was pretty. That boys story is more sad and depressing and he didn’t provoke any of the bullying (like flashing himself online). What about the current kids who are thinking of suicide because of bullying, why are we not helping them. Are we just waiting for them to kill themselves so the media can make a profit from their pain and death.

    I’m sorry but I don’t take women who say stupid stuff like all men are rapists and men are biological mistakes as good and smart people. I think they are pathetic hate mongering victims

  48. U mad?

  49. I don’t take trolls who can’t tell the difference between a period and a question mark “as” good and smart people.

  50. Bo-ring! If you’re going to take over a year to formulate a reply, make it a good one!

  51. That boys story is more sad and depressing and he didn’t provoke any of the bullying (like flashing himself online).

    Yay, another compassionate human being engaging in victim-blaming. That’s nice. Not.

    Also, quit calling him a misogynist? Nope. That he once tried to deliberately trigger a rape victim he assumed to be female by talking about the rape in sexually explicit and violent terms proves that he’s a misogynist. It’s sufficient evidence.

  52. That boys story is more sad and depressing

    Why? Because he’s a boy?

    and he didn’t provoke any of the bullying (like flashing himself online).

    What an asshole you are.

  53. Well that was different! And boring. I’m going back to replacing the heel pads on my boots, cutting rubber is more interesting than that was.

  54. Anonymouslazycat

    I’m sorry but I don’t take women who say stupid stuff like all men are rapists and men are biological mistakes as good and smart people.

    I’d have to agree with you on this part. Fortunately, very few women actually say stuff like that! Isn’t it nice how these things work out? Why, it’s almost as if feminists aren’t the reprehensible she-beasts that you think they are.

  55. Angelo C. Loustalot

    Rest in Peace Amanda Todd, may God have mercy on your soul. No one deserves to be bullied, we all make mistakes. Amanda todd was just being a young teenager full of life and vigor.

  56. Wow, the comments on the Youtube video are disgusting. So many people getting upvotes for blaming her.

  57. That’s an atheist for ya’ – they don’t care about anyone or anything but themselves. They love to bully, harass, threaten, and troll people (especially people who are already hurt and damaged enough as it is) because it makes them look “edgy”. They devote their lives to spreading hatred and misery. They’re the reason why the world is so screwed up. They’re all just a bunch of hateful, judgmental, intolerant, self-obsessed, pretentious bigots.

  58. Really Kris? Maybe you haven’t noticed but an awful lot of the people going after the “Amazing Atheist” for being a terrible human being are also atheists. Like any religious group, atheists are a mixed bag. Let’s not get into ugly stereotyping–especially not blaming the society’s ills on a small, denigrated minority.

  59. Thank you for that lovely opinion, Kris. What a wonderful first impression you’ve made.

    You probably think only white, straight, cis men are atheists, too. Now, I am, but there’s plenty of diversity at, say, FreeThoughtBlogs.

  60. Sure, the tiny minority of the global population that are atheist are totally responsible for all the world’s woes. Taking over from the Jews, who used to hold that honor.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 17,151 other followers

%d bloggers like this: